Search
START TYPING AND PRESS ENTER TO SEARCH

SC admits SFLC petition challenging internet shutdowns to ‘prevent’ exam cheating

Sep 9, 2022Internet Control

Last Updated on November 3, 2024 by freespeechcollective

The Supreme Court of India issued notice to the Union Government on a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by Software Freedom Law Center, India (SFLC.in) challenging the imposition of Internet Shutdowns to prevent cheating in examinations in the five states of Gujarat, Rajasthan, Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, and West Bengal today.

The bench comprising Chief Justice of India (CJI) U.U. Lalit, Justice Ravindra Bhat and Justice P.S. Narasimha asked the government for the standard protocol on internet shutdowns.

Internet shutdown in Assam during recruitment exam for government posts (courtesy NDTV report)

A total of 12 instances of exam-related Internet Shutdowns have been documented on SFLC.in’s Internet Shutdowns Tracker, the first and only real-time internet shutdown tracker in India. There have been 3 additional shutdowns, 2 in Assam and One in West Bengal after the petition was filed bringing the total number to 15.  These 15 instances alone amounted to over 80 hours of disruption of the internet services. 7 out of the 15 suspensions, including the  recent one in October 2021, were imposed in the state of Rajasthan.

The SFLC petition said that India is the leader in imposing Internet Shutdowns globally. The phenomenon of blanket internet bans during examinations to prevent copying has become common in several Indian states. Such bans primarily target mobile internet services.

SFLC.in Internet shutdown tracker

In January 2020, the Supreme Court in Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India  upheld that the Internet is a medium for exercising the fundamental freedoms guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(g). The court also ruled that the orders to shut down the internet must be made public.

Adv Vrinda Grover argued on behalf of the petitioners that the guidelines issued in Anuradha Bhasin vs. Union of India (2020) 3 SCC 637 were persistently not complied with. The Union of India which was imp leaded as a party respondent on the direction of the Court, has been asked to clarify the standard protocol with respect to the grievance raised and the extent of compliance thereto by the States. The Union has been directed to file its reply within 3 weeks. The next hearing will take place after 4 weeks.

The PIL was being argued by Ms. Vrinda Grover, Adv., assisted by Mr. Prasanna S (Advocate on Record), Soutik Banerjee,  Swati Arya & Yuvraj Singh Rathore, Advs. and lawyers from SFLC.in Mishi Choudhary (Founder, SFLC.in), Prasanth Sugathan (Legal Director), Radhika Jhalani (Volunteer Legal Counsel ) , Mythili Srinivasamurthy (Volunteer Legal Counsel), Arjun Adrian D’Souza (Volunteer Legal Counsel).

Read a copy of the petition here:

sflc-petition-internet-shutdownsDownload

Internet Control
“Internet Control” tracks incidents where authorities have weaponised digital rights of their citizens, through actions such as internet shutdowns, slowdowns, blocking, restricting or slowing down cell phone network and/or usage, especially to crush public dissent, censor spread of news and events, and so on. This category also includes banning of apps, for example those made in China.

Related

January 15th, 2020

Internet Control

Kashmir Internet ban to continue, Nodal officers to check usage on a daily basis
Internet restrictions on people of the Kashmir valley will continue with some additional facilities thrown in for citizens to access the Internet but under heavy and daily supervision! As expected, the Jammu and Kashmir government conducted its ‘review’ of all orders (within four days of the Supreme Court order directing it to do so) regarding […] Read More

May 19th, 2020

Internet Control

Still no full Internet restoration in Kashmir: SC order
Despite pleas by doctors and students, the people of Kashmir are still denied full restoration of Internet. A Supreme Court order on a petition filed by the Fountation for Media Professionals and the Private Schools others, merely said that a high powered committee would look into the matter. National security and human rights have to […] Read More

May 31st, 2023

Internet Control

Manipur Violence and Communication blockade: “The Internet shutdown disconnects you from the outside world”
In Manipur, even as the ethnic violence continues unabated, information has been a major casualty. Journalist Ninglun Hanghal, told Free Speech Collective that the scale of violence was unimaginable and the Internet shutdown has contributed to peoples’ misery as it crippled communication and disrupted lives. The fragile inter-community dynamics were violently disrupted on May 3, […] Read More