How does the sting on the sahayak system affect the security of the nation? – Justices Ranjit V. More and Bharati H. Dangre

May 9, 2019National Security - Journalists

Last Updated on November 3, 2024 by freespeechcollective

In a trenchant order, Justices Ranjit V. More and Bharati H. Dangre, quashed the charges against Quint journalist Poonam Agarwal of abetment to suicide and of violating provisions of the Official Secrets Act (OSA).

The case followed the sting operation the journalist had conducted to exposed the pernicious ‘sahayak’ system in which she interview five persons in Deolali, Nasik. One of them, Lance Naik Roy Mathew, allegedly committed suicide as his body was found in the Deolali barracks. In the order, the judges said:

“We fail to understand how the video clippings. which contains a conversation about the Sahayak system, or the ‘buddy system’, affects the security of the nation. At the most, it can be said to be a footage exposing the manner of working of the Army, which is in contrary to the suggestions of the report of the Parliamentary Committee, which had suggested to prohibit the use of Army jawans in the capacity of Sahayak and being entrusted with duties which would act as an insult to the jawans. On viewing the clippings recorded by applicant Poonam and its uploading on social media, we do not find that the clippings contain any information affecting the security of the State or the sovereignty and integrity of the country. “

Read the full judgement here :

poonam agarwal order bombay high court

 

Related

Barely 10 days into the new year and sedition was put to use, this time against prominent writer Hiren Gohain in Assam, along with activist Akhil Gogoi and journalist  Manjit Mahanta. And four days later, Delhi police filed its chargesheet in the sedition case against JNU student leaders Kanhaiya Kumar, Umar Khalid and Anirban Bhattacharya, […] Read More
Lawyers representing journalist Kishorechandra Wangkhem who is detained under the National Security Act (NSA), speak to Laxmi Murthy about why slapping a preventive detention law is overkill. Imphal-based journalist Kishorechandra Wangkhem, who was taken into custody by the Manipur police on November 26, 2018, was ordered to be detained for 12 months under the draconian […] Read More
The Bombay High Court has quashed a case against Quint journalist Poonam Agarwal and Kargil war veteran Deepchand, charged with spying under the Official Secrets Act and abetment to suicide after her sting on the ‘sahayak’ system published in February 2017. The bench, comprising Justices Ranjit More and Bharati Dangre, heard arguments on the case […] Read More